Jacoburline wrote:The argument is unsound because it does not count for the possibility of any other religion being the correct one. It assumes, incorrectly, that there are just two possibilities in that regard.
Actually, almost all religious assumptions are based on false dichotomies. Good/evil, Heaven/Hell, life/afterlife (unless you believe in reincarnation) all rely on making a choice between one option or its "opposite" with the religion heavily favoring one particular choice.
Because anyone of sound mind will chose whatever choice is personally most appealing, religions use negative reinforcement to make one choice always seem unappealing. Evil is "bad" and will get you the consequences of punishment and judgment. Heaven is a place of bliss, while Hell is a place of eternal torment. If you must choose between good or evil, only an insane man would choose evil.
By setting up false dichotomies, religions create a demand for something that doesn't exist (salvation, escape from suffering, etc.) and then those religions fill that demand by promising to supply things which they can't deliver. The reason that religions cannot deliver is because the false dichotomies are never real to begin with. They take something which does exist (people with malicious intent) and extrapolate it into extremely polarized fantasy (Evil, Hell, God's wrath, etc.)
This is the reason religions don't want you to question their dogma. The only way to keep people believing in a false dichotomy for any period of time is if nobody questions that belief. As soon as people start asking questions, the game is up. By appealing to authority (i.e. the Bible is infallible and God doesn't make mistakes) people are assured that they have no reason to question their beliefs.
If someone goes to two different doctors and gets two different diagnoses, they would want another opinion. Or at the very least, they would want to know which doctor was better qualified to diagnose their condition. There are many religions, yet nobody is interested in a second opinion. People are not interested in a second opinion on religion because they have been convinced that their first "doctor" (the religion they were brought up with) is perfect and that they do not need a second opinion. Thus, people feel perfectly fine with believing in whatever dichotomy religion tries to sell them even though they would not do such a thing with any other aspect of their lives. Religion is a special case because people are convinced it is correct. Even if the diagnosis is wrong (i.e. the religion is not true) people are unwilling to even look at the evidence.
Religion is a perfect system because it promises to be the supplier of the demand that it itself created, while simultaneously convincing people not to question the necessity of the demand which religion claims to fulfill. This is the reason there are so many scam artists and immoral people using religion to further their own personal position. Religion is the "wombo combo" of brainwashing. If people are already deathly afraid of eternal torture, they are easily manipulated because of their fear. All the scammer has to do is know which buttons to push.