by Jeshi » August 19th, 2011, 10:46 pm
[quote="qv"]
He didn't say what kind of sensations his friends have. It probably isn't a case of perfectly hallucinated tails/ears... I know I've done some files, and if I focused, I could crappily feel some stuff, but yeah, nothing lasting or all that extensive.
And of course it is technically biologically possible, seeing as there are documented cases of people who had phantom limb sensations for non-existent parts. Like a third arm, or something. It's called a Supernumerary phantom limb. The problem is nobody knows why it happens, and in any case, you may be right that that wouldn't happen in the case of tails.[/quote]
Supernumerary limbs though aren't that difficult to imagine though. Your sense that keeps track of if your limbs are missing(its real name is way too long to remember) is usually going "Two arms. Two legs. Two hands." but if it malfunctions, then it wouldn't be hard to imagine it going "Three arms. Two legs. Two hands." and creating the sense of one being there. Once that sense of a third arm(and since our brains are mapped to know what arms should feel like anyways) is there, other senses would probably work around it.
People's senses malfunction at all time. It's called minor hallucinations and they're more common than people think because they tend to associate the word hallucination with huge obvious stuff. Seeing things in the corner of your eye, hearing someone say your name before falling asleep, it's all very normal. It happens for similar reasons as tripping or suddenly losing balance. Just with your senses.
[quote="qv"]
Well, but you can get a person to sniff smelling salts as if they were roses. This is stuff that smells bad enough to wake up people that are freaking unconscious, so it seems evident that there is a legitimate perceptual change as opposed to simply acting out the suggestion.
As for whether you could have that all the time without actively thinking about it... well, that I don't know.[/quote]
See, this is where a lot of people misinterpret the effects of hypnosis. You're jumping just a step too far. The brain processes the chemicals and scents of smelling salts the same. Hypnosis makes the conscious reaction be that of roses and have the thoughts process it as roses. It still smells terrible, you just think of that smell as what roses should smell like and hypnosis convinces you that the smell should smell good.
It's similar to the placebo effect. When you have symptoms of a disease, you usually expect certain things and exaggerate the sickness and your reactions. It makes sense to do this on both an evolutionary and social level. If everyone around you thinks you're sicker than you are, you'll get higher priority treatment.
When you get the "treatment" you stop exaggerating the symptoms because you have no more need for the attention. So you say "yeah I feel better now" but really you're just as sick as before.
If you smell something bad, you exaggerate your reactions to alert everyone about how bad it smells, hypnosis can convince you not to do this and then from there push your reactions to another extreme, those of telling everything that this thing smells like roses.
[quote="qv"]
...bawww. I was hoping this wouldn't come up.
No, it's not in the DSM-V, no, it is not officially recognized as a clinical disorder. But its existence is theorized, and...
...
...okay, so there's not really anything I can say about that.
Curses.[/quote]
Even if it was in DSM-V, whether that warrants being supportive of it is still another debate. Pedophilia, Sociopaths, and Psychopaths are all in the DSM-V. We are not typically supportive of these people(although maybe we should be more supportive of sociopaths since most of their problems stem from the fact that they feel human emotions but are incapable of expressing it, resulting in people assuming they don't have emotions and treating them like shit. Which causes them to develop more mental disorders.)