Moderator: EMG
ranmafan wrote:well I've talked to ppl who have phantom ears and tails sensations..that alone I'd be happy with..maybe have my my register seeing my body as a fox, I know I can't physically change into a fox. And who/what is Samatha Sez?
bandler wrote:ranmafan wrote:well I've talked to ppl who have phantom ears and tails sensations..that alone I'd be happy with..maybe have my my register seeing my body as a fox, I know I can't physically change into a fox. And who/what is Samatha Sez?
Your comments remind me of problems that kids can develop from playing too much D&D (Dungeons & Dragons) or other role play games. There is great allure in escapism, especially these days in Amerika.
ranmafan wrote:well I've talked to ppl who have phantom ears and tails sensations..that alone I'd be happy with..maybe have my my register seeing my body as a fox, I know I can't physically change into a fox. And who/what is Samatha Sez?
Jeshi wrote:ranmafan wrote:well I've talked to ppl who have phantom ears and tails sensations..that alone I'd be happy with..maybe have my my register seeing my body as a fox, I know I can't physically change into a fox. And who/what is Samatha Sez?
Phantom limb sensations for limbs you wouldn't normally have sounds pretty difficult. How would you know what it's supposed to feel like if it's a limb you've never had and the body isn't trained to have?
Humans have ~25 senses(the five senses thing is an ancient starting point that was never meant to convey every sense.) One of those senses is about knowing where you are relative to yourself, AKA knowing where your hand is without looking at it. It's why you can touch your nose with your eyes closed.
Another sense is knowing which of your limbs are still attached. And then there's the sense of being touched.
Normal phantom limb sensations are caused when these senses malfunction. Someone may lose a hand but their senses don't catch up on it so they still feel like it's there. Or you'll think a limb you do have is somewhere else than it is. Or you'll feel something touch you that's not there.
All three of these senses would have to be heavily modified in order to have phantom limb for limbs the brain doesn't know anything about. It's not biologically possible and if it is possible it would be very very difficult to pull off with hypnosis.
Either these people you've talked to are lying, in denial, or heavily exaggerating.
Hypnosis can modify subconscious thoughts not the actual processes with which your brain processes information such as sight and touch. The best you can get is to vividly imagine seeing something or feeling something and that is not a passive thing that you could just have all the time without actively thinking about it.
You have unrealistic expectations. Also, Species Identity Disorder is not in the DSM-V. I'm pretty sure it isn't a real mental disorder.
Jeshi wrote:Phantom limb sensations for limbs you wouldn't normally have sounds pretty difficult. How would you know what it's supposed to feel like if it's a limb you've never had and the body isn't trained to have?
Jeshi wrote:All three of these senses would have to be heavily modified in order to have phantom limb for limbs the brain doesn't know anything about. It's not biologically possible and if it is possible it would be very very difficult to pull off with hypnosis.
Either these people you've talked to are lying, in denial, or heavily exaggerating.
Jeshi wrote:Hypnosis can modify subconscious thoughts not the actual processes with which your brain processes information such as sight and touch. The best you can get is to vividly imagine seeing something or feeling something and that is not a passive thing that you could just have all the time without actively thinking about it.
Jeshi wrote:Also, Species Identity Disorder is not in the DSM-V. I'm pretty sure it isn't a real mental disorder.
qv wrote:
He didn't say what kind of sensations his friends have. It probably isn't a case of perfectly hallucinated tails/ears... I know I've done some files, and if I focused, I could crappily feel some stuff, but yeah, nothing lasting or all that extensive.
And of course it is technically biologically possible, seeing as there are documented cases of people who had phantom limb sensations for non-existent parts. Like a third arm, or something. It's called a Supernumerary phantom limb. The problem is nobody knows why it happens, and in any case, you may be right that that wouldn't happen in the case of tails.
qv wrote:
Well, but you can get a person to sniff smelling salts as if they were roses. This is stuff that smells bad enough to wake up people that are freaking unconscious, so it seems evident that there is a legitimate perceptual change as opposed to simply acting out the suggestion.
As for whether you could have that all the time without actively thinking about it... well, that I don't know.
qv wrote:
...bawww. I was hoping this wouldn't come up.
No, it's not in the DSM-V, no, it is not officially recognized as a clinical disorder. But its existence is theorized, and...
...
...okay, so there's not really anything I can say about that.
Curses.
Jeshi wrote:qv wrote:
Well, but you can get a person to sniff smelling salts as if they were roses. This is stuff that smells bad enough to wake up people that are freaking unconscious, so it seems evident that there is a legitimate perceptual change as opposed to simply acting out the suggestion.
As for whether you could have that all the time without actively thinking about it... well, that I don't know.
See, this is where a lot of people misinterpret the effects of hypnosis. You're jumping just a step too far. The brain processes the chemicals and scents of smelling salts the same. Hypnosis makes the conscious reaction be that of roses and have the thoughts process it as roses. It still smells terrible, you just think of that smell as what roses should smell like and hypnosis convinces you that the smell should smell good.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests